I grade movies with letters. The criteria is based largely on the intent of a movie, not just an objective grading system. For example, I would consider Casablanca an A+. I would also consider Raiders of the Lost Ark an A+. Both are effective, well-crafted, and leave me wanting nothing more, despite one being an iconic romantic drama, and the other being a b-movie on steroids. Context is important. So with that established, here’s a rundown:
A – Excellent. Multiple elements stand out
B – Good. Usually has a few standout elements
C – Average. Nothing exceptional, but not a total waste
D – Cannot be recommended. Unintentional comedy likely rampant.
F – Unwatchable. Not even a drinking game can save it.
Pluses and minuses, of course, would indicate that they’re either on the low or high end of that criteria.
TV, on the other hand, is much more subjective. The episodes can really only be judged by the other episodes and seasons of a show. My philosophy is to assess each show as a whole with a grade (ie Scrubs: B), and grade each episode as either above expectations, meets expectations, or below expectations.
The shows I plan on reviewing regularly include:
The Office (A)
House (B-)
Scrubs (B)
Dexter (A+)
and How I Met Your Mother (A-)
I’ll likely pick up some new shows on the way, but 5 shows to keep tabs on seems like a modest start.
August 24th, 2008 at 5:47 pm
Hooray! I am officially putting you on my ‘friends’ page.
August 30th, 2008 at 10:30 pm
definitely agree with you on the A+ ranking of Dexter
mad props.